No, Poshmark’s New Home Market is Not a Good Thing

PrettiBoneInsights, Thoughts12 Comments

Poshmark had a really good thing going. Prior to May 30, 2019, they were focused on having a platform that exclusively catered to women's, men's and kid's clothing. Now with the addition of the "Home" category, I'm not sure if I feel the same way. Don't get me wrong, those that we're already making money on Poshmark is not at risk, I just don't have a good feeling for those of us that are already struggling with sales. 

This change can be broken down into 2 different conversations. The first being what kind of effects this will have on Poshmark as a company and the second being what effects this will have on sellers. Since I know my readers are all sellers, I will only be addressing the later in this post.

Please note that my opinion is based on the information that is available to the public as of this writing.

Let's start this off with a fun fact. As of May 30th, 9:56 p.m. Pacific, there are currently 5,080 items listed under the "Home" category with 138 items sold.

Walk Before You Run

If you're a seller that's doing well, by all means dip your toes in another market. The problem is, how do we define "doing well"? Sure, a lot of us will argue that doing well is subjective and relative but there's got to be a line drawn. I'm a numbers person so I always check people's numbers and compare it to how big their boast game is. And let me tell you, a lot of us are all bark and no bite. Do I sound like a snob by saying this? Sure. Is it the truth? Yes. You can take my word for it or not, I just know I did my homework.

So where am I going with this? The majority of us are not selling as much as we're claiming we are through our posts on social media. With that said, why are we trying to add more stuff on our plate that will take away our focus when we're not even doing well at what we're currently doing? Please don't think I'm saying this as I'm on my high horse, I've worked my ass off to know the ins and outs of Poshmark. I even went as far as to create this blog to teach as many people as I can about reselling clothes on Poshmark so believe me when I say I'm still the same humble me. 

I hope my point is clear; make sure you get good at one thing before jumping onto something else. I didn't say become an expert, I'm saying just be at a level where you're not worried about sales because it's so damn consistent!

Look at it this way, before you become a Jack of all trades, strive to be a Queen/King at something first.

Diffusion of Resources

Time, money, storage space, energy are just a few of the resources you have as a reseller. The most basic thing in Economics is understanding that all resources are finite. Knowing this, you should make all of your resources work in your favor by using them efficiently. Think of it this way, if you're not using those resources effectively now with your current process, what makes you think it will change when you have to focus on another category? Let me give you an example that has to do with storage. Most of us operate our reselling business out of our homes and are up to our necks with clothing all around the house or garage. Now imagine allocating more room to hold all these other knick-knacks. Take that same principle and look at how it will affect your other resources.

Again, if you're "doing well" with the current Poshmark categories, pay this no mind. 

Bang for Your Buck

From the prices I see in the Home category on Poshmark, I know without a doubt my money is better spent on buying clothes. The margins are just simply higher. I know some of you will disagree but I'm looking at how much I get my clothes for when it comes to this topic. I'll cut this short since this is a truly subjective point because people get things for different prices so it doesn't leave me much room to argue with.

The obvious takeaway here is for you to watch your margins by allocating your money appropriately.

Shipping and Weights

Of course, I had to mention weight and shipping! Scroll through the available items on Poshmark's Home category and tell me how many items will exceed the 5lb. limit. Remember, after, 5lbs. you must purchase additional postage at your expense. One of the biggest reasons as to why I love selling clothes is due to clothes being so lightweight. I only had to buy additional postage about 4 times and it was all due to 10+ piece bundles. Needless to say, additional postage will chip away at your profits because it gets really! See the schedule below:


If you're selling something heavy, you're better off shipping using the USPS Flat Rate service because the limit is 70lbs. The problem is, Poshmark doesn't provide this option, at least not currently.

What is Strategy?

If you've read my past posts, you'll know by now reference my favorite author, Michael Porter, a few times already. With that said, ingrain this in your mind when it comes to your strategy for reselling anything:


I could've made this entire post off of this quote alone, it's really that important. Read it, read it again, remember it, apply it! This quote is the driving force behind how I've developed PrettiBone to what is today in such a short amount of time. 

The sad thing about strategy is that most people don't even know what the definition of strategy is when they're throwing around the word. What they call strategy is usually just a tactic which is different from strategy. By truly understanding strategy, I promise you will be better at whatever business endeavors you're after. 

Here's a shameless plug for my book recommendations by Michael Porter. Thank me later.


I don't agree with the new Home category at all on Poshmark. The above points I made are not everything that's on my mind so I decided to end this post with an unstructured rant about it...

If you're doing really well on Poshmark with clothes, do and sell what the hell you want, apparently, your technique and process work. For the majority of us, really ask yourself what kind of burden you're putting on yourself and think of the consequences. If you're not doing well with the main category on a platform, why would you think you will do any better by adding another category? I'm gonna bet my money that it's not the market, it's most likely how they're doing things that don't net them sales. This is not me bashing them, this is me suggesting that they work on their process first before they spread themselves thin. I don't think the grass is greener on the other side. The Home market is filled with too many variables that you must account for and this will drain your time and money. 

Sellers that aren't doing well with sales and jumping into the Home category reminds me of how those same people put so much emphasis on being an "Ambassador" or "Affiliate" which by the way was a total head fake. Worry about your damn process and sales first before you embark on something new. Trust me, if you think you're going to make more money by diversifying your catalog, you got this game all wrong. Some of us would even go as far as to drop certain clothing categories from their inventory to be more efficient while others are trying to get frisky with an ENTIRELY new sector?!

Why did Poshmark introduce the Home market besides for the obvious money? I think it's because they're trying too much to be a one-stop shop which in turn will make the platform look like a garage sale. There are already a few MAJOR players in the "everything under one roof" market and why Poshmark is trying to get into this dog fight is beyond me. 

Don't believe for one second I'm opposed to change or I feel threatened in any way with the new Home market. I totally believe that you can make more money by casting a wider net, but ask yourself are you remotely ready to even take on that responsibility. Humans have this natural problem where we go for the next shiny object and totally forget about focusing, again the "Affiliate" program is a great example. Really, $10 is enough for you to stop what you're doing? Again, quit looking at the next damn shiny object and FOCUS

Again, for those that think I'm taking this too seriously, I'd gladly accept your compliment.

Make sure to leave your comments below, I know you guys have a lot to say about this.

12 Comments on “No, Poshmark’s New Home Market is Not a Good Thing”

  1. First. Love your new look. I only started selling in Jan. Before I spent a few mos researching and everyone said just clean out your closet and start there. There are some things that just need to donate. Now everyone says pick up stuff around your house an put that on your closet. OMG WHAT A MESS. I already am seeing I have too many categories going to get it right. I can’t wait to read your posts. I’m a realist. I want the real talk. Thanks again

    1. If you’re a realist you came to the right place! Correct, I think people need focus more and quit jumping around all the damn time.

  2. First of all, thank you. I too am glad to have stumbled upon your postings on IG and have thoroughly enjoyed following your journey. (I also work in film/tv (in the production department) and for all the years I was doing it full time, I’m still in disbelief that you’ve managed to hold down both these careers simultaneously!)
    For months now I’ve continued the gathering phase of Inventory at home, while continuing to do my research online to figure out strategically what will work best for me. Yeah, that may be a bit of fear of failure involved with delaying my jumping in, but I’ve always been one to go into anything I do 100% prepared to the best of my abilities. I have really loved what I’ve seen of Poshmark thus far and have been excited to become a part of the community, but at the same time continued to question the success I will have because clothing is not the majority of my inventory. And in the last few weeks, having done some local sales, I’ve excelled in selling home goods. So figuring out my game plan in splitting my inventory between sites has been challenging, as I would much rather go all in on just one site.
    So for me, this is the absolute opportunity that I’d been hoping for. I do agree however that shipping will be the absolute downfall, but will begin with lightweight items until that issue is resolved.
    Thank you again for creating this open forum, as for me personally you have been an inspiration in allowing me to believe I too can do it and be successful. Xoxo

    1. Thanks for the kind words Angela. Yes, the home goods category might be good for some people but I believe for the majority it will not play out well due to most of us not being ready to “multi-task”. Unless you’re talking about ebay, it is really difficult to have “everything under one roof” is a tough one.

  3. I’m wondering if they are doing this because of the IPO this fall, and if they plan to buy up the smaller players such as Mercari.

    1. Mercari is a publicly traded Japanese company. It’s valuation is way higher than Poshmark’s. No way Poshmark will buy Mercari any time soon.

    1. I’m afraid people wont think of “Fashion” when they think of Poshmark in a couple of years

  4. I’m still on the fence with this HOME idea. Almighty dollar at best. I’ve been on Posh since nearly the beginning that I truly hope it won’t effect anything I’ve been doing. I may dip my toes in small jewelry displays since those aren’t heavy and go with my theme. Catch 22 for most people at best though with majority of clothing that’s stagnant like you’ve suggested. Curious how Posh will delve into weight and shipping. I could only hope for USPS flat rate all the way around- or allow first class since mine aren’t close to 5lbs and I always feel bad for buyer. Thank you for your amazing blog and in-depth posts. So glad I stumbled upon your profile on IG! @vintagestatus P.S. It’s also important to note that PayPal will play a huge role in this monetarily. Especially with Posh already following in eBay’s footprints with siding with buyers and lackluster help of the seller.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.